Kemintiri mergée et Closed Session

[François V.]

On m'avait posé au tournoi la question de savoir si, lorsque Kemintiri mergée jouait closed session, elle pouvait voter dans le référendum.

Pour faire court, elle ne peut pas voter :

"Joshua Duffin" <jtduf...@yahoo.com> wrote in message news:367aplF4u03m8U1@individual.net...
> LSJ's argument is this: when Kemintiri is playing a card requiring a
> justicar, that card treats her as being a justicar. That's why Closed
> Session lets her vote. (I found this very unintuitive because I had
> thought of Closed Session as applying an effect to the duration of the
> referendum, not an effect resolving immediately - and it has to apply
> its effect immediately on being played for it to treat Kemintiri as a
> justicar. But I can't see any problems with it working the way Scott is
> obviously reading it, so I'll have to revise my intution on Closed
> Session.

Sorry. I was just thinking in terms of "as played" and "while in
play". I wasn't thinking about the extended duration effects, a topic
which had already been covered in the "as a vampire" suite.

Your intuition is correct.

Kem plays Closed Session as a Camarilla justicar, but no longer
qualifiers as either a justicar or a Camarilla during the
polling, so the Closed Session will exclude her.

(Reversal of previous ruling)

--
LSJ (vtes...@white-wolf.com) V:TES Net.Rep for White Wolf, Inc.
V:TES homepage: http://www.white-wolf.com/vtes/
Though effective, appear to be ineffective -- Sun Tzu

Faudra que je l'ajoute à mon petit topo sur Mata Hari et ses copines...

[Stone]

un peu de nécro pour rappeler que depuis le RTR du 7/7/7, si saian Kemintiri joue Closed Session, elle sera considérée comme camarilla pour les effets de CS pendant le referendum (là encore un lingering effect), donc elle pourra s'exprimer (dixit François V. dans sa contribution à WSS 2007). c'est un REVERSAL d'anciens rulings.